$10 Tier Episodes

After two girls vanish under mysteriously similar circumstances, their community is forced to confront their darkest fears.

When a 16-year-old girl disappears and is later found murdered in her hometown of LaPorte, Indiana, authorities spend the next 20 years searching for answers until someone comes forward and changes everything they thought they knew.

When a teenage boy goes missing around Christmas, no one expects his disappearance to explode into a sprawling twisted tale of infamy, horror, and murder.

In April 1974, two men robbed an electronics store in Ogden, Utah. They thought they left no witnesses, but they were wrong.

When a vulnerable transgender woman goes missing, her friends and family search for answers.

A beloved priest dies in New Mexico. Another goes missing in Montana. Are they isolated incidents, or is there a serial killer out there targeting Catholic priests?

A senseless act of violence rips through a family and changes their lives forever.

An unknown man dies under suspicious circumstances in a Catholic church in Boise, Idaho.

Kent Leppink was murdered in 1996 near Hope Alaska. Many media sources attribute his death to a love triangle gone wrong but the truth is so much more complicated.

A young woman is getting ready to start the biggest adventure of her entire life, until it’s stolen from her in the worst way possible.