When a 16-year-old girl goes missing from her bedroom in October of 1996 and days later is found brutally murdered, a small town is shocked to discover not only how she died – but who among them was her killer…

Three beloved small town Indiana carpenters head to a new job one summer day in 1999 and never make it home.

When three women are found murdered in Tennessee, Arkansas, and Mississippi, investigators from each state are worried they may have a serial killer on their hands.

When the body of a vibrant high school English teacher is found in a local body of water, her family concludes that it must have been a tragic accident.

When 11-year-old Shauna Howe doesn’t come home from a Girl Scouts Halloween party, her mother Lucy immediately fears the worst.

When an elderly woman is brutally murdered in her own apartment and her case goes cold, her family wonders if they’ll ever get justice.

When a local teenager is found dead in a disturbing scene, the panicked community confronts the possibility that witchcraft might be to blame.

When 19-year-old Chad Maurer is discovered dead three hours away from his home, Chicago authorities are quick to assure his family that there was no foul play.

After a night out with friends, a young woman is never seen or heard from again.

When 15-year-old Chaim Weiss is found murdered in his high school dorm room, investigators quickly realize that only a select group of people had access to his building.

When the burned body of a young au-pair is found in her employer’s garden, police immediately arrest them on suspicion of murder.