$10 Tier Episodes

Ashley takes another crack at fiction in this creepy story, Why I Stopped Babysitting, written by Eleni Vassiliadis.

This became one of Edgar Allen Poe’s most infamous stories because when he first released it people didn’t realize it was fiction and it caused quite the panic.

On a new Ask Me Anything, Ashley and Brit answer all our fan club questions about ourselves!

Make sure to listen to the full Lynn Messer episode first! These were just our lasting “WTF” thoughts after that episode.

Warning: Some Explicit language – you’re saying… “What? I don’t remember swear words in The Tell Tale Heart”… Yeeaaaa.. I know. I decided to do something a little different.

In need of a laugh? We’ve put together a compilation of Crime Junkie bloopers with Ashley and Brit!