$5 Tier Episodes

When a teenage boy goes missing around Christmas, no one expects his disappearance to explode into a sprawling twisted tale of infamy, horror, and murder.

In April 1974, two men robbed an electronics store in Ogden, Utah. They thought they left no witnesses, but they were wrong.

A beloved priest dies in New Mexico. Another goes missing in Montana. Are they isolated incidents, or is there a serial killer out there targeting Catholic priests?

An unknown man dies under suspicious circumstances in a Catholic church in Boise, Idaho.

Kent Leppink was murdered in 1996 near Hope Alaska. Many media sources attribute his death to a love triangle gone wrong but the truth is so much more complicated.

In 1954, the Claypool Hotel in downtown Indianapolis played host to a gruesome murder when a young woman’s body was found crammed into a dresser drawer.

In this audio extra, we tell you the story of a murder some people believe could be connected to the death of Gina Hall.

A teenage girl is found dead in 2003 over Thanksgiving weekend. For years her manner of death was labeled undetermined.

Episode Summary After two men are convicted of the kidnapping and murder of 10-year-old Jeanine Nicarico, huge questions remain about what happened the day she died…and if the right people are truly being punished for the crime. Episode Info[dica_divi_carousel...

After 21-year-old Brittany Zimmermann is murdered, her family embarks on a years-long mission to find justice.

Lisa Kimmell was just 18 years old when she set out from Denver, Colorado in her brand new Honda CRX with the license plate that featured her childhood nickname, LIL MISS.