$5 Tier Episodes

When Patrick Mullins goes missing in January 2013, no one knows where he went or why he would leave his seemingly happy life behind.

When four young men, just starting their lives, go missing within a week of each other, investigators must work across multiple townships and jurisdictions to trace the trail of clues each boy left behind.

When a young mother and her five children are brutally murdered in their home, investigators immediately kick off a search for answers from the one man who was supposed to love and protect them.

When a young graduate student at Yale University seems to vanish into thin air—just days before her wedding—investigators initially suspect they’re dealing with a runaway bride.

When the bodies of multiple young men are discovered along the Indiana/Illinois state border, police fear that they have a serial killer on their hands.

When 13-year-old Yara Gambirasio is abducted less than half a mile from her home in Northern Italy, investigators quickly run out of leads.

When a young woman mysteriously dies of electrocution… the authorities rule it an accident.

When five-year-old Melissa Brannen vanishes in a crowd of 200 people in 1989, evidence leads authorities to one man.

On this Ask Me Anything, Ashley and Brit answer some of the most popular questions asked by YOU – our fan club members!

When Sydney Loofe doesn’t show up to work the day after she posted to social media about going on a date, her friends and family know something is not right.