MISSING: Carolyn Killaby
When a young woman goes missing in November 1995, no one knew just how close they were to a monster lurking in the area. What starts as a night out after an argument with her husband… ends in tragedy that’s left the family with so many questions.
For our friends in the Deaf and Signing community, you can view an ASL version of this episode.
If you or anyone you know is thinking about suicide or substance abuse, support is available::
We’d love to speak with you and see how we can support.
If you’re a law enforcement agency or family member of one of the people we mentioned in this episode, or if you’re looking for more coverage on a case, please reach out. You can email us at:
Episode Source Material
- December 13, 2002: State v. Smith
- Centralia Chronicle (Centralia, WA): Man denies guilt in Clark County death by Associated Press via NewspaperArchive.com.
- Department of Corrections Washington State: Board Hearings.
- Department of Corrections Washington State: What are Parole (PRE) cases?
- Forensic Files: Missing in Time (season 6, episode 1) via Peacock.
- Longview Daily News (Longview, WA): Disappearance leads to charge by The Associated Press via Newspapers.com.
- Prison Legal News: $4.47 Million in Washington Negligent Supervision Settlements and Verdicts via Web.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Brother arrested in death of sister; body found nude by Sally James via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Man gets life term for sister’s slaying by Cynthia Tank via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Woman missing after night in bar; detectives work to rule out foul play by John Branton via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Hunt goes on for missing woman by John Branton via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Detectives chasing leads in case of missing woman by John Branton via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Woman Still Missing via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Convicted murderer sought by John Branton via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Convicted murderer sought by John Branton via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): ‘Where is my sister?’ by John Branton via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): ‘Where is my sister?’ by John Branton via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): FBI seeks Orchards man by John Branton via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Search for missing woman goes national by John Branton via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): A Family In Limbo by John Branton via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): A Family In Limbo by John Branton via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Tipsters call ‘Mystery’ line in Killaby case by Randall Black via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Suspect arrested in Killaby murder case by John Branton and Randall Black via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Killaby murder suspect survives surgery by Randall Black via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Killaby murder suspect survives surgery by Randall Black via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): TV show’s role in arrest is speculative by John Branton via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Smith served with arrest warrant by Randall Black via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Smith served with arrest warrant by Randall Black via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): DNA match implicates murder suspect by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): DNA match implicates murder suspect by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Officials sign papers to extradite murders suspect via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Judge declares Carolyn Killaby officially dead by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Murder suspect Smith extradited by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Smith pleads not guilty to murder via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): TV show takes credit in arrest of murder suspect by John Branton via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): TV show takes credit in arrest of murder suspect by John Branton via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Prosecutors ask to file new charge in death by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Accused killer of Killaby turns down plea bargain by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): DNA test gets OK for Smith trial by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): DNA test gets OK for Smith trial by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Smith’s attorneys point to husband of Carolyn Killaby by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Smith’s attorneys point to husband of Carolyn Killaby by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Smith trial blends mystery, science by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Smith trial blends mystery, science by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Husband can’t be named as suspect in trial, judge rules via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Defense suggests Killaby may have planned to vanish by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Witnesses describe search for Killaby by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Cellmate says Smith talked of coverup methods by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Jurors might hear about murder of defendant’s sister in Killaby trial by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Jurors hear of Smith’s ’82 murder by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Smith defense disputes DNA results by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Jurors to deliberate in Killaby murder case starting Monday by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Smith convicted of Killaby murder by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Smith convicted of Killaby murder by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Smith convicted on first vote, jurors say by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Killaby family sues over killer’s release by Bruce Westfall via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Kidnapping, rape evidence lacking in Killaby case by Erik Robinson via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Kidnapping, rape evidence lacking in Killaby case by Erik Robinson via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Victim’s family berates killer by Stephanie Thomson via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Victim’s family berates killer by Stephanie Thomson via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Experts to examine newly found skull by John Branton via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Police say skull not that of teen who disappeared in 1987 by John Branton via Newspapers.com.
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Killaby’s killer commits suicide by Stephanie Rice via Newspapers.com. (1)
- The Columbian (Vancouver, WA): Killaby’s killer commits suicide by Stephanie Rice via Newspapers.com. (2)
- The Daily Herald (Everett, WA): Murder charge finally served in year-old case by Associated Press via Newspapers.com.
- The News Tribune (Tacoma, WA): Hope fades for woman missing 6 weeks by The Associated Press via Newspapers.com.
- The Spokesman-Review (Spokane, WA): Killer sentenced to life in prison via Newspapers.com.
- Unsolved Mysteries (season 9, episode 10) via Prime Video.
- Walla Walla Union Bulletin (Walla Walla, WA): Former inmate may be linked to missing woman by Union-Bulletin and Associated Press via NewspaperArchive.com.
- Walla Walla Union Bulletin (Walla Walla, WA): Ex-local man shot by police in Florida by Union-Bulletin and Associated Press via NewspaperArchive.com.
- Walla Walla Union Bulletin (Walla Walla, WA): Former WW man brought back to Washington to face murder charges again by Union-Bulletin and Associated Press via NewspaperArchive.com.
Suggested Episodes
WANTED: Justice for Rhys Pocan & MMIW Part 1
In 2021, we set out to cover the case of Rhys Pocan, a 35-year-old Indigenous woman who was murdered in Wisconsin in the ‘80s. But while we were in the field, we uncovered a disturbing pattern of murders with similarities to Rhys’ that were just too blatant to ignore. So, we spent the next three years working with local and federal law enforcement to try and get to the bottom of it.
WANTED: The Keddie Cabin Killer
A family’s brutal murder rocks a tiny California town and leaves behind too many unanswered questions.
WANTED: Justice for MMIP
May is Missing and Murdered Indigenous Persons Awareness Month, and we want to highlight some of the many cases involving members of Native American communities that so often go underreported and underserved, and thus unsolved.
Join our Fan Club to listen to this episode and more!
Unlock all of the exclusive benefits and dynamic listening experience as a Crime Junkie Fan Club member.
Join the Fan Club now to reap the rewards!
