MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: Casey MacPherson-Pomery and Caleb Guillory
Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory had plans to ring in the new year on the beautiful Caribbean island of Anguilla. But before the proverbial ball could drop, they were both dead. The four people with them that night haven’t spoken publicly about the incident since — and until they do, the mystery of what happened to Casey and Caleb will remain on the island.
For our friends in the Deaf and Signing community, you can view an ASL version of this episode.
Episode Information:
If you want to contribute to Justice for Casey & Caleb, visit their GoFundMe here.
We’d love to speak with you and see how we can support.
If you’re a law enforcement agency or family member of one of the people we mentioned in this episode, or if you’re looking for more coverage on a case, please reach out. You can email us at:
Episode Source Material
- People.com: Her Brother Died Mysteriously in Anguilla — Now Woman Says Wife, Friends Have ‘Something to Hide’, By Jeff Truesdell
- People.com: 2 Men Died Mysteriously on Island Paradise, Leaving Relatives to Ask: What Do the Wives Know?, By Jeff Truesdell
- KTVL News: Two men poisoned and killed off the coast of St. Martin, by Carsyn Currier
- Kobi 5 (NBC): Family seeks answers after loved one killed abroad, by Newsroom Staff
- MurderInParadise.org
- GoFundMe: Justice for Casey & Caleb
- People Magazine: Were they murdered? By Sandra Sobieraj Westfall and Jeff Truesdell
- KOBI5: Family hires private investigator to solve island death, by Newsroom Staff
- Royal Anguilla Police Force – report. Dated June 18, 2019
- Globe Newswire: People Magazine Cover Story Exposes Death of Two Americans in Shocking and Suspicious Circumstances in Anguilla
- Truth and Justice for Casey and Caleb Facebook page
- Investigation Discovery: Still a Mystery, Season 3, episode 7 – “Best lives cut short”
- KOBI 5 (NBC): Family seeks answers after loved one killed abroad
- 18 U.S. Code § 1119 – Foreign murder of United States nationals
- Royal Anguilla police Facebook page: Police investigate sudden deaths
- Healthline.com: The Lowdown on Sassafras (MDA). Last medically reviewed on March 23, 2020
Suggested Episodes
WANTED: Justice for Rhys Pocan & MMIW Part 2
In 2021, we set out to cover the case of Rhys Pocan, a 35-year-old Indigenous woman who was murdered in Wisconsin in the ‘80s. In Part 2, we look into cases of two other female dismemberment victims in Wisconsin with striking similarities to Rhys Pocan’s.
WANTED: Justice for Rhys Pocan & MMIW Part 1
In 2021, we set out to cover the case of Rhys Pocan, a 35-year-old Indigenous woman who was murdered in Wisconsin in the ‘80s. But while we were in the field, we uncovered a disturbing pattern of murders with similarities to Rhys’ that were just too blatant to ignore. So, we spent the next three years working with local and federal law enforcement to try and get to the bottom of it.
WANTED: The Keddie Cabin Killer
A family’s brutal murder rocks a tiny California town and leaves behind too many unanswered questions.
Join our Fan Club to listen to this episode and more!
Unlock all of the exclusive benefits and dynamic listening experience as a Crime Junkie Fan Club member.
Join the Fan Club now to reap the rewards!
