Episode Summary
When three women are found murdered in Tennessee, Arkansas, and Mississippi, investigators from each state are worried they may have a serial killer on their hands. And while the total number of victims is up in the air to this day, one fact remains the same: someone – or someones – got away with murder.
Episode Info
Jellico, Tennessee.
Campbell County Jane Doe.
Lisa Nichols, formerly known as the Crittenden County Jane Doe.
DeSoto County Jane Doe.
Jerry Johns.
Michelle Inman, formerly known as the Cheatham County Jane Doe.
The Knox County Jane Doe.
The Greene County Jane Doe.
Miami County Jane Doe.
Wetzel County Jane Doe.
A map of the locations of all of the victims discussed thus far in the episode.
Additional photo of Lisa Nichols, the Crittenden County Jane Doe.
Tracy Housel.
Dade County/Rising Fawn Jane Doe.
1990 newspaper article on 45-year-old Delia Trauernicht.
25-year-old Lisa Atwell.
Margaret Calciano, the Berks County Jane Doe, identified in 2003.
Alex Campbell, Elizabethton High School sociology teacher.
Kim Mills, found in 1978.
Pulaski County Jane Doe, found in 1985. She is still unidentified.
Priscilla Blevins, found in 1985 and identified in 2009.
Roane County Jane Doe, found in 1987. She is still unidentified.
Patrice Corley, found in 1990 in Ohio.
Simpson County Jane Doe, found in 2001.
21-year-old Tina Farmer, formerly known as the Campbell County Jane Doe, identified in 2018.
28-year-old Espy Black-Pilgrim, formerly known as the Knox County Jane Doe, identified in 2018.
17-year-old Elizabeth Lamotte, formerly known as the Greene County Jane Doe, identified in 2018.
Stacy Lyn Chahorski, formerly known as the Dade County or the Rising Fawn Jane Doe.
Mugshot of Jerry Johns.
Karen Knippers, discovered in 1981 in Missouri. She is not thought to be connected to the Bible Belt Strangler, but her case is still unsolved.
Dawn Clare Plonsky, formerly known as the Simpson County Jane Doe. Found in 2001 and identified in 2022.
Donna Nelton, formerly known as the Benton County Jane Doe, identified in 2022.
14-year-old Tracy Walker.
Marcia King, formerly known as the Miami County Jane Doe.
Check out the Elizabethton High School Bible Belt Strangler Profile.
If you have information on the deaths of Lisa Nichols, Michelle Inman, Elizabeth Lamotte, Lisa Atwell, Tracy Walker, Delia Trauernicht, Kim Mills, the Pulaski County, Roane County or Memphis Jane Does, please contact the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation at 1-800-TBI-FIND (824-3463) or [email protected].
If you have information on the death of Espy Black-Pilgrim, please contact the Kentucky State Police at 606-573-3131 or [email protected].
If you have information on the death of Donna Nelton, please contact Lt. Hunter Petray at [email protected], or the Benton County Sheriff’s Office Criminal Investigation Division at 479-271-1009.
If you have information on the death of Priscilla Blevins, please contact the Licking County Sheriff’s Office at 740-670-5555 or [email protected], or submit an online tip form.
If you have information on the death of Karen Knippers, please contact the Pulaski County Sheriff’s Office at 573-774-7948.
If you have information on the identity of the DeSoto County Jane Doe, please contact the DeSoto County Sheriff’s Office at 662-429-TIPS (8477).
If you have information on the identity of the Wetzel County Jane Doe, please submit an anonymous online tip form.
Join our Fan Club to listen to this episode and more!
**Please note** All Fan Club episode sources are listed directly on their episode show notes in the Fan Club app.