WANTED: Monsters of Ohio Part 2

Play episode

After Asenath Dukat, 11 more young girls in Ohio were kidnapped and murdered. Many under eerily similar circumstances. Is this the work of one or two predators or are there many monsters, still on the prowl in Ohio?

Listen Now

For our friends in the Deaf and Signing community, you can view an ASL version of this episode HERE.

The Case

Asenath “Seannie” Dukat

Asenath Dukat
Photo Found HERE

Kelly Prosser

Kelly Prosser
Photo Found HERE

Tiffany Papesh

Tiffany Papesh
Photo Found HERE

Brandon Lee Flagner

Brandon Lee Flagner
Photo Found HERE

Tammy Seals

Tammy Seals
Photo Found HERE

No Photo Available

Joanne Hebert

Damita Sullivan

Damita Sullivan
Photo Found HERE

Tammy Seals

Tina Harmon
Photo Found HERE

Ernest Holbrook

Ernest Holbrook
Photo Found HERE

Ray Rucker

Ray Rucker
Photo Found HERE

Krista Harrison

Krista Harrison
Photo Found HERE

Dawn Marie Hendershot

Dawn Marie Hendershot
Photo Found HERE

No Photo Available

Debbie Smith

Robert Buell

Robert Buell
Photo Found HERE

Amy Mihalijevic

Amy Mihalijevic
Photo Found HERE

Barabara Barnes

Barbara Barnes
Photo Found HERE

The Serials Killer Apprentice

The Serial Killer’s Apprentice by James Renner
Photo Found HERE

Monsters of Ohio map

Map where the 12 young girls were killed in Ohio in the 80s
Photo Found HERE

Episode Sources

My name is Ashley Flowers and I'm a Junkie, too.

I've been crime-obsessed since birth and the only thing I love more than true crime is my dog, Charlie. My work with Crime Stoppers has led me to do this podcast, and I am so excited to be your new true crime dealer.

More from this show

Episode Categories

Episode
Episode 10