Mary Ashford and Barbara Forrest were two 20-year-old women killed in the same town, on the same night, after an evening of dancing… 157 years apart from each other. The eerie similarities have some wondering if supernatural forces are at play.

When two young women are brutally murdered in 1982, the residents of Morris County, New Jersey, are worried there might be a serial killer in their midst. But the unthinkable happens mere WEEKS later that turns this whole case upside down – and ultimately ends a winter of horrors.